Poshmark Vs thredUp – Which Is Best?

April 1, 2020

video library
body shape
work style
Now Trending:
I'm Angela!

Welcome! I'm so glad you stopped by. Make sure to check back every Friday for a new style tip. Our goal is to help you go from, I have nothing to wear to having a closet packed with items you love that fit and flatter.

Join the Petite Revolution and never miss the Fashion Fix of the week


This content has been archived. It may no longer be relevant

This was originally going to be a post about Poshmark Vs. ThredUp – Which Is Better? You know, the stylish girls’ version of Foreman Vs Frazier.

I figured it would be the perfect follow-up to January’s Clutter-Free Closet post. (If you missed that piece of blogging brilliance (surely you know I’m kidding), you can check it out here. Oh! And make sure to snag your free checklist.)

Calvin Klein White Booties

Calvin Klein Booties – Never Worn – Sold In 2 Weeks – Don’t Know How Much They Charged, But I Made $35

Things Changed When…

I went online, ordered a ThredUp bag, and sent in the three pictured pieces. (I put the results in the pic captions, in case you’re curious.)

Then, I went on YouTube to figure out how Poshmark worked. I got sucked in and ended up watching three videos by three different re-sellers.

An hour later, all I could think was, ‘What the heck?!?’

And not a good, what the heck.


More of a, ‘There is no way in heck we have time for that nonsense.’

Those Poshmark chicks are serious. I mean, it’s their job! One of them mentioned she makes 100K a year re-selling clothes she buys in bulk at Goodwill. And let me tell you, she deserves it – it’s a flippin’ boatload of work.

If you want to check her out, here’s the link.

Go ahead and call me lazy, but their advice to us was:

  • Take pictures
  • Try to remember how much you paid for it
  • Research the style number
  • Find the RN number (whatever the heck that is)
  • Take measurements
  • Create a compelling description
  • And then finally, Ship It
  • And you better make it look pretty because whoever buys it is going to judge you on what the package looks like?!?

Not to mention, listening to them, it sounds like Poshmark is another social media platform.

One of the girls went on and on about fighting for likes and shares and Ambassador status and re-sharing five times a day, and a bunch of other stuff I don’t remember now. Because honestly, the whole thing gave me a touch of PTSD.

And listen, no matter how much free time we have right now, there are better ways for us to spend it.

Like binge-watching the new season of Ozark.

Michael Kors Navy & White Shift Dress

Michael Kors Navy & White Shift Dress – Still For Sale $23

So this article morphed into ThredUp is Awesome! And the perfect way to sell or give away clothes that need to be evicted from your closet because they no longer serve you.

And here’s why:

  • They send you the bag
  • They take the pictures
  • They post it online or send it to one of their retailers
  • They come up with the price
  • They ship the item to the buyer

The only thing for us to do is throw the stuff in the bag and leave it for your mail carrier. (They even give you a label.)

Easy peasy right. Want your own polka-dot bag? Tap here.

Ted Baker Pastel Striped A-Line Dress


It’s not all sunshine and unicorns…

  • They can and do deny items. (They claim to only accept 40% of the average Closet Clean Out bag) For example, they rejected the Ted Baker dress above, and since I told them I didn’t want it back, they donated it. (They will return it to you. But you have to pay for shipping.) And I figured, what’s the point? I give it away, or they do – it’s still going to some girl who’ll enjoy it and look super cute.
  • They won’t take clothes that are older than 5 years.
  • Everything has to be in crazy good good condition.

Good for The Environment

They brag a lot about how by up-cycling your clothes they saved 10 billion gallons of water and 128 million pounds of carbon dioxide. I have no idea how they did that math, but even if those numbers are close to accurate, sending them clothes is a pretty easy way for us to help the planet.


They also have a straight donation bag available. And from now until the end of May, they’re donating $15 to Feeding America for every donation kit they receive.

How awesome is that!

Not to get on a soapbox, but… no kid in this country should ever go hungry. So, if you have anything you don’t love – please order a bag.

That’s A Wrap

After all that, I’m thinking ThredUp is the ultimate win-win. Win-win.

They make it easy – either you or a charity makes money – and we end up with only items we love in our closet.

So, give it a shot and let me know what you think. Or is there is another thrift app you like better? Tell us all about it.

‘Til Next Week.

Hugs and Happy Shopping.

Our Style Addiction - Angela

P.S. Did you miss last week’s post about outfits to wear while we’re working from home? No worries – click here and you’ll be all sorted out.

P.P.S. Swing by later this week. We’re going to chat about Moto Jackets and a newly discovered jewelry brand you’re gonna’ love.

Reselling Clothes Online

+ show Comments

add a comment

- Hide Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Browse All Categories


Body Shape

Work Style

so hot right now

Meet Your Petite Style Coach.

Hi! I'm Angela. High-achieving Petites hire me to create a closet full of clothes they love to wear.

After working as an executive in the fashion and beauty industry for over 20 years, it became clear, successful Petites needed more than a personal shopper or a random influencer on Instagram telling them to buy the latest trendy jeans.

They needed a step-by-step approach to Petite Style. And that’s why I created the S.P.A.R.K. style system.

hey sunshine!


Angela - Style Coach

Privacy Policy >

Terms & Conditions >

© Angela Foster 2021


Some articles may contain affiliate links meaning we may receive compensation at no additional cost to you.

follow along on instagram:

Then Sit Back And
Relax As Petite Style Tips Magically Appear In Your Inbox.

Join The
Petite revolution